Unlearning efficiency to inhabit uncertainty

Desaprendiendo la eficacia para habitar la incertidumbreDiedrick Brackens | The Cup is a Cloud | Los Angeles, 2018

By Carlos Mendoza-Álvarez

It has been seven months since I left Boston, after five years of academic life in the frenetic gears of American efficiency, with a special challenge in the background that consisted of translating the master ideas of modern Latin American and European theology to multicultural groups of white students from the United States, and others who came mostly from Korea, China and Japan, plus some from Turkey, El Salvador, Colombia and Chile.

The initial courtesy of colleagues, both students and professors, gradually gave way with a few of them to a genuine conversation, always with respect for individual work prevailing and few exchanges about the meaning of our work as an academic community.

I cherish the best moments of those encounters, such as the colloquiums to which we gave the decolonial tone of “conversations” (Beyond Global Violence Initiative), where we were able to open windows so that colleagues from the north and south could listen to each other, with certain difficulties in moving between both worlds, not only because of the differences in language but also because of the diverse experiences that sustain the body, thought and the word.

What we all enjoyed most were the gatherings in the warmth of Valentina and Domingo's Chilean-Bostonian home, exceptional hosts to both our hearts and our palates. There, we could share, with greater intimacy and freedom, the ideas and intuitions that had lingered in the auditoriums of the Chestnut Hill campus. Sometimes, with Francis's Italian flair, assisted by Martín, and in the warmth of Neto's affability in his home, always ready to welcome us like a true Salvadoran, each of us found our place in the ebb and flow of conversation, wine, and song. In those welcoming homes, we received friends from Brazil, Mexico, El Salvador, Colombia, Puerto Rico, Spain, Ohio, Illinois, New York, Indiana, and California, passing through Massachusetts. And there, new projects for colloquiums, books, and trips were born, projects that continue to surprise and inspire us all to this day.

But everything was interrupted by my sudden departure from US territory in the Trump era, leaving that seed of cordial intelligence sown in living memory.

In the following months, back home and with interwoven journeys between South Africa, Turkey, Brazil, and Chile, I faced the challenge of seeing diverse worlds with new eyes, paying special attention to "those who dwell in the shadows of the shadows of the shadows." Thus, I was led—by the pure gift of my hosts during those travels—to experience moments of devastating and beautiful simplicity, such as accompanying Lance from the University of Pretoria to the Congolese refugee farm on the outskirts of the city. There, the pain of being homeless for more than five years was evident in his eyes, but within them also shone a glimmer of dignity that I still carry in my heart and spirit as a call to closeness.

I vividly remember the walk along the cliffs of Cape Town with Grant and his team, where on a sunny but cold South African winter morning we contemplated how the two great oceans, the Atlantic and the Indian, meet, sometimes with fury and other times with tenderness. A metaphor for intertwined worlds.

I also recall with emotion the ecumenical Taizé-style prayer led by my Dominican brother Claudio, along with Eda, a resident of Istanbul, and a group of African and Ukrainian students living there. Interspersing mantras for peace in various languages, they gathered in the dim light of the Church of the Preachers, located near the Galata Tower. It was a glimpse of what Pentecost means, albeit only as a bastion of spirituality amidst a vibrant, modern Muslim culture that looks with curiosity at what happens within these Christian enclaves.

I treasure in my memory the simple and brief Eucharist in the small wooden chapel of the Jesuits in Tirúa, on a small altar covered with a Mapuche textile and adorned with an oriental-style oil lamp that created a luminous twilight, on a spring morning in Wallmapu, in the far south of Chile. I had the grace to share with them for a few days their joyful dispossession, as travelers accompanying the Mapuche people in defense of their territory, their language, and their ancestral spirituality.

In each of those experiences, the question of how to build bridges to share spiritual intimacy between people and communities of diverse traditions lingered for me. And I remembered the rituals we have explored at Re-existe, precisely seeking new languages to celebrate together our precarious lives, open to hope, according to diverse ancestral traditions, from indigenous peoples to Abrahamic religions and the secular inner lives of those who are individuals or groups without religion.

Back in the land of my ancestors, now free from the daily pressure of the classroom and the unbearable academic meetings, I'm beginning to understand what it means to unlearn efficiency. To enjoy the free time of otium, beyond the negotium, as I told you here a few weeks ago.

But it's about more than just slowing down. Something compels me today to live in the moment. otherwise as a renewed inner life and the place as my homeland. I seek an external rhythm between morning walks, religious duties, attentive reading of books piled on my desk for years, and more creative writing, loosening my pen and exploring new literary genres. But it's not enough. There's something more I sense on the horizon, the search for a "place" to put down roots, grow slowly, and blossom, following that creative intuition of Ivan Illich and Jean Robert (The place in the space age). The place and time where inspiration flows will gradually become clearer in the coming months.

Now that I have time to “do nothing,” I feel invited to reinvent myself every day. I am certainly working in the present on wonderful intellectual projects, such as the collaborative book on political theology—with the introduction I am writing, inviting fifteen contributors from eight different countries to the table of words to reflect on “the common good” in times of great catastrophe—whose manuscript I am revising with the support of Francis and Nathan, dear colleagues I met at Boston College, and which will be published next year by a prestigious publisher in the United States.

I am delighted to review the scripts for the documentary and the comic book – by Juan and Katsumi respectively – which will commemorate the past meeting Re-exists 2025. The Spirit connecting the peripheries which we will soon share in the digital world to continue strengthening our resistance against the evil that surrounds us today as systemic violence. This initiative has been creating a multifaceted space-time where we learn to re-exist, reinventing ourselves alongside other survivors.

And with excitement, I also imagine—along with some Dominicans who are seeking new expressions of the charism of preaching in our unprecedented context—what will emerge from our meeting on Nicaea last October in Istanbul. Situated in today's cities and villages, which are like laboratories, we seek how to communicate to humanity the joy of being inhabited by the divine and human Word that redeems us, whether rooted in the secularized world or amidst diverse spiritual traditions.

Encouraged by these vivid memories and by the ongoing work that connects with my deepest desire, I now face the challenge of "stopping" the whirlwind of efficiency, unlearning to live and think only in terms of production. It is a journey in reverse, but above all, an implosion of a dizzying desire, to return to the still center of body, desire, thought, and spirit from which it flows another mode of existence.

And then I will learn to let myself be inhabited and moved – as I discussed with my friend Juan Carlos La Puente in the heart of the pandemic (Mutual accompaniment in the divine Ruah)– because of the uncertainty as a gift and surprise of the fluttering of Life that encourages us all.

Mexico City, November 15, 2025

Note: I would appreciate your feedback at the end of this page.

Comments

6 responses to “Desaprendiendo la eficacia para habitar la incertidumbre”

  1. Martin. Avatar

    Until dignity becomes the norm.

  2. larryjoseb18faed701 Avatar
    larryjoseb18faed701

    “Unlearning efficiency…” (a tremendous challenge that also harbors so many good intentions in the shadows of shadows…) what a good word!

  3. anabertaplab54289e7a Avatar
    anabertaplab54289e7a

    Interesting observations on serving others from a place of inefficiency or something similar? Unforgettable experiences that will surely contrast if you take on a specific project with specific tasks in which you accompany the population that needs to get ahead.

  4. Dolores de aguinaga Avatar
    Christmas Eve pains

    I believe that in this capitalist world where worth is measured by production and efficiency, thinking and reflecting are a luxury we should strive for, as they nourish us, give us inner peace, and at the same time can bring us closer to others.

  5. jesus albino mendoza alvarez Avatar
    Jesus Albino Mendoza Alvarez

    Reflection on "the meaning of our work as an academic community" is also absent from the institution where I work. Even in higher education and graduate programs in physics, mathematics, and engineering, this reflection should be central to our work, especially when we consider artificial intelligence, control and automation engineering, or data science. We have also imported the "frenetic machine of American efficiency" to Mexico and adopted it in teaching practices that only seek to meet bureaucratic indicators, which ultimately prove sterile in terms of our students' understanding of the world. And so time passes and is consumed without us becoming aware of our place in the world.

  6. Antonio U. Avatar

    Carlos, you propose a shift that, on the surface, defies contemporary common sense. In a world obsessed with metrics, performance, and optimization, suggesting the “unlearning” of efficiency sounds almost subversive. However, your argument isn't anti-action; it's a critique of the absolutization of a criterion that has colonized every aspect of life.

    This entry engages with "Anthropology of Sovereignty," where you examined how modern authority tends to legitimize itself through results rather than meaning. Here, that logic shifts to the existential plane: when effectiveness becomes the supreme measure, uncertainty is perceived as failure. You reverse the equation. Uncertainty is not a flaw in the system; it is a constitutive condition of historical existence.

    There is also a perceived affinity with "Deus Absconditus." If God does not manifest himself under parameters of total control, then the experience of faith—and humanity—necessarily includes areas of non-dominion. Living with uncertainty is not equivalent to resignation, but to a lucid acceptance of limitations. Unlearning efficiency opens space for a broader rationality, where patience, listening, and discernment regain their centrality.

    The text doesn't encourage passivity, but rather a reconfiguration of our criteria for action. Instead of first asking "Does it work?", you suggest asking "Is it faithful?", "Is it fair?", "Is it true?". This shift profoundly alters our way of being in the world.

    In times of systemic acceleration, your proposal introduces a critical pause. Uncertainty ceases to be a paralyzing threat and becomes a space for maturation. There, effectiveness regains its relative place and human life, its depth.

Deja un comentario

English

Descubre más desde Carlos Mendoza-Álvarez

Suscríbete ahora para seguir leyendo y obtener acceso al archivo completo.

Seguir leyendo